Rethinking Worship Evangelism?

September 21, 2007 | Filed Under church, ecclesiology, missional |

worship-evangelism.jpgThere is probably a good chance you have already seen this article from Sally Morgenthaler, author of Worship Evangelism. Morgenthaler’s article was first published in Rev! Magazine but recently was offered on the Allelon website as well as this month’s Next Wave ezine.

I used a portion of Worship Evangelism as part of the curriculum for a course on Worship from 1999 to 2003. I appreciated her emphasis on challenging seeker targeted churches to rethink performance based “worship” to that in which seekers would sense and experience the presence of God. Morgenthaler challenged church leaders to consider the evangelistic potential of authentic worship.

However, today Morgenthaler has become increasingly uncomfortable with the “worship-driven subculture.” She has become convinced that the focus on culturally relevant, authentic worship has been at the expense of understanding and living the Christian faith with a missional perspective.

I would recommend reading the entire article on one of the sites linked above, but here is a sample of Morgenthaler’s struggle:

Two years ago I taught my last seminar focused solely on worship. A year ago I disbanded my worship resource site, Sacramentis. My colleagues were concerned. How could I leave the work I’d begun? Did it mean I no longer believed worship was important? Who was going to take up the torch of worship evangelism? Was I just going to waste my legacy? Was I crazy?

Maybe I was, but a storm had been brewing in my soul for five long years. I remember meeting with the worship leader of a well-known church in the fall of 2000. He had followed my work and respected many of my viewpoints. When we met over coffee, he shared a concern he’d had for a while over my book Worship Evangelism. In his view, Worship Evangelism had helped to create a “worship-driven subculture.” As he explained it, this subculture was a sizeable part of the contemporary church that had just been waiting for an excuse not to do the hard work of real outreach. An excuse not to get their hands dirty. According to him, that excuse came in the form of a book—my book.

He elaborated. “If a contemporary worship service is the best witnessing tool in the box, then why give a rip about what goes on outside the worship center? If unbelievers are coming through the doors to check us Christians out, and if they’ll fall at Jesus’ feet after they listen to us croon worship songs and watch us sway back and forth, well then, a whole lot of churches are just going to say, ‘Sign us up!’ ”

To be honest, I wasn’t surprised. The attitude he described certainly didn’t fit every congregation out there in contemporary-worship-land, but it matched too much of what I’d seen. The realization hit me in the gut. Between 1995 and 2000 I’d traveled to a host of worship-driven churches, some that openly advertised that they were “a church for the unchurched.” On the good occasions, the worship experience was transporting. (I dug a little deeper when that happened. Invariably, I found another value at work behind the worship production: a strong, consistent presence in the community.)

Too many times, I came away with an unnamed, uneasy feeling. Something was not quite right. The worship felt disconnected from real life. Then there were the services when the pathology my friend talked about came right over the platform and hit me in the face. It was unabashed self-absorption, a worship culture that screamed, “It’s all about us” so loudly that I wondered how any visitor could stand to endure the rest of the hour.

Were these worship-driven churches really attracting the unchurched? Most of their pastors truly believed they were. And in a few cases, they were right. The worship in their congregations was inclusive, and their people were working hard to meet the needs of the neighborhood. Yet those churches whose emphasis was dual—celebrated worship inside, lived worship outside—were the minority. In 2001 a worship-driven congregation in my area finally did a survey as to who they were really reaching, and they were shocked. They’d thought their congregation was at least 50 percent unchurched. The real number was 3 percent.

Bookmark and Share

Leave a Comment

If you would like to make a comment, please fill out the form below.

Name

Email

Website

Comments